EverBank
EverBank Performance Savings
By Alex Compton · Last verified
The former TIAA Bank, back under its old name and paying near the top of the market
Insurance: FDIC insured up to $250,000 through EverBank, N.A.
Account Terms History
A dated record of APY, fees and opening requirements. New changes append to this table; prior terms remain visible.
| Observed | APY | Monthly fee | Minimum | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-07 | 3.90% (as of September 2026) | $0 | None | Archive record · no attached snapshotLegacy snapshot; event-level evidence was not attached at the time |
Primary-source verification log
Append-only evidence ledgerEvent-level primary-source attachments begin with the September 2026 verification system. Older records remain visible but are not retroactively presented as evidenced.
Features
- ▸3.90% flat APY with no minimums and no caps
- ▸No monthly maintenance fees, no mobile deposit fees
- ▸Full bank under the hood: checking, money market, and CDs available
- ▸Performance Money Market sibling adds check writing if you need it
- ▸Florida-based bank with decades of history (formerly TIAA Bank, re-rebranded 2023)
- ▸Daily compounding
Pros
- +Consistently one of the top nationally available rates without gimmicks
- +Real chartered bank with a full product shelf, not a deposit-brand shell
- +No balance hurdles, activity requirements, or rename games
Cons
- −App and online experience are dated next to Ally or Openbank
- −Customer service hours and responsiveness get mixed reviews
- −Headline rate is pitched at new accounts; verify your rate periodically
Our Take
EverBank is the grown-up rate leader: a real bank paying 3.90% without hurdles, boosts, or expiration dates. It lacks the polish of the fintech apps and the ecosystem of Ally, but for the core job of holding cash at a top rate with boring reliability, it is arguably the strongest pure HYSA on this page. Check your statement rate twice a year, as with any bank advertising 'new account' APYs.
Best for: Set-and-forget savers who want a leader rate from a traditional chartered bank
Open at EverBank →Last verified 2026-09-07
Head-to-Head Comparisons
Ranked On
Rate this card
Be the first to rate it
Commentson EverBank Performance Savings
Comments are stored in your browser during our community preview. Accounts, moderation and cross-device sync arrive with Credit Compound Community.